1. Diocesan Bishop: Supernatural Evidence not established  (Non Constat de Supernaturalitate)

 

 

(a). Imprimatur, Nihil Obstat or Positive Remarks by Bishop

 

4 Visionaries, Garabandal, Spain 1961-1965

Ivetka Korcakova and Katka Ceselkova, Litmanova, Slovakia 1990

 

(b). No Remarks by Bishop

         

Patricia Talbot (Pachi), Cuenca, Ecuador 1988-1990

Joseph Reinholtz, Hillside, Illinois U.S.A.,  1990-1996  (Our Lady of the Cross)

Sandy Ramussen, Falmouth, Kentucky, U.S.A., 1992-1995 (Our Lady of Light)

Neil Harrington Jr, Enfield, Connecticut, U.S.A., 1992

 

(c) Mixed Remarks or Controversy with Bishop

 

Three Children, Sabana Grande, Peurto Rico, 1953

6 Visionaries, Medjugorje, Bosnia-Herzegovnia, 1981-Current  (Our Lady, Queen of Peace)

Christina Gallagher, Gortnadreha, County Mayo, Ireland 1988-1992 (Virgin Mary, Queen of Peace)

Renato Baron, San Martino di Schio, Italy, 1985-2004 (Mary, "Queen of Love")

 

(d) Negative Remarks by Bishop

 

Julia Kim, Naju, Korea, 1985 -Current (Our Lady of Naju)

 

2. Diocesan Bishop:  Established not to be Supernatural (Constat Non Supernaturalitate)

 

 

(a). Imprimatur, Nihil Obstat or Positive Remarks by Bishop

 

                Estella Ruiz, Pheonix, Arizona, U.S.A. 1988 (Our Lady of the Americas)

Fr Jack Spaulding and 9 Young People, St Maria Goretti Church, Scottsdale, Arizona, U.S.A.,  1988-current

 

 (b). No Remarks by Bishop

 

Theresa Antonia Lopez and Veronica Garcia, Denver, Colorado, U.S.A. 1991-1994

Allan Rudio, Manila, Phillipines, 1993 -1998

 

(c). Mixed Remarks or Controversy by Bishop

 

N/A

 

(d) Negative Remarks by Bishop

 

Mama Rosa Quattrini, San Damiano, Italy, 1964-1970 (Our Lady of the Roses)

Debra Geileskey, Toowoomba, Australia, 1983 –1993

Patricia de Menezes, Surrey, England, 1985 (“Our Lady of Surbiton” and “The Way of Divine Innocence”)

Vassula Ryden, Switzerland, 1985 -2003

Dr Mary Jane Evan, Lincoln, Nebraska, U.S.A. 1990

Gianna Talone Sullivan, Emmitsburg, Maryland, U.S.A. 1988 -2000 (Our Lady of Emmitsburg)

William Kamm,” Little Pebble” Nowra,  New South Wales, Australia 1990’s

John Leary, Rochester, New York, U.S.A. 1993

Judiel Nieva, Agoo, Philippines, 1989 -1993

 

3. Currently Being Investigated

 

(a). Imprimatur, Nihil Obstat or Positive remarks by Bishop

 

Teresa Higginson, Neston, England, 1874 (Sacred Head of Jesus)

Sr Josefa Menendez, Spain, 1890 -1923

Katrina Vogl, Munich, Germany, 1926

Mother Elisabetta-Eugenia Ravasio, Grenoble, France, 1932

Marthe Robin, Chateauneuf-de Galaure, France 1930-1981

Sr Consolata Betrone, Saluzzo, Cuneo, Italy, 1930

Berthe Petit, Belgium, 1938  

Sr Mildred Mary Neuzil, Fostoria, Ohio, U.S.A., 1954 (Our Lady of America)

Gladys Herminia Quiroga de Motta,  San Nicholas, Argentina 1983 -Current (Our Lady of the Rosary)

Carol Nole  and Barbara Matthias,  Santa Maria, California, USA 1988 and 1990 resp. (Our Lady of the Immaculate Heart, Queen of the Universe)

Joseph Januszkiewicz, Malboro, New Jersey, U.S.A. 1989-1994 (Yellow Flower of Peace)

Dina Basher (Stigmatist),  Mozul, Iraq 1991

Barnabus Nwoye, Enugu State, Nigeria 1995 -Current

 

(b). No Remarks by Bishop

 

Sister Marie Marthe Chambon, Chambery, France 1871

Emma Blanche Curotte, Verdun, Quebec, Canada 1920

Jeanne-Louise Ramonet, Kerinzen, France, 1938 -1995

Matous Lasuta, Turzovka, Czechoslovakia, 1958

Therese Neumann, Konnersreuth, Germany, 1962

Luz Amparo Cuevas, El Escorial, Spain, 1980 -1992 (Our Lady of Sorrows)

9 Seers, Kinshasa, Zaire, 1984 –1988

12 Children, Oliveto Citra, Italy 1985 –1989 (Our Lady of Consolation, Madonna of the Castle, Queen of Love, Our Lady of Graces) 

 

 

(c). Mixed Remarks or Controversy with Bishop

 

                Novice Teresita Castillo, Lipa, Phillipines, 1948

Cyndi Cain, Vista, California, 1991 -1995

 

(d) Negative Remarks by Bishop

 

Luisa  Picaretta, Corato, Italy, 1878

Ursula O’Rourke, Tom Cliffe, Barry Buckley, Breda Coleman, Melleray Grotto, Ireland 1985

Maureen Sweeney Kyle, Cleveland, Ohio U.S.A. 1985

Beulah Lynch and Mark Treanor, Bessbrook Grotto, Northern Ireland 1987-1988

4 Visionaries, Inchigeela, County Cork, Ireland, 1985-1987